Planning Explorer

North York Moors

North York Moors logo
Browse section
Plans Plans

Refusal Reasons for Application - NYM/2015/0107/FL

Site AddressHill View Barn, Staintondale 

Details

  • Application NumberNYM/2015/0107/FL
  • Site AddressHill View Barn, Staintondale
  • Property AddressHill View Barn, Staintondale, Scarborough, YO13 0EL

Reasons 1

By virtue of its size, bulk, design and prominent location in open countryside, the proposed building is considered to have a seriously detrimental impact on the character and appearance of this rural landscape within the National Park. As such the development would be contrary to Core Policy A and Development Policy 3 of the Local Development Framework which seek to minimise sporadic development in the countryside and conserve the special character of the National Park.


Reasons 2

The land associated with this proposal is 0.823 Hectares in size. The property and small area of land is considered to be adequately served by the existing timber clad barn and domestic garage which provide over and above the required space to serve the associated area of paddock land. The land and property therefore does not justify a building of the size proposed under this application which is contrary to the requirements of Development Policy 12 which requires that there is a functional need for the building and that its scale is commensurate with that need. In the absence of any overriding justification for the proposed development it is considered that the proposed building conflicts with Core Policy A and Development Policy 12 of the Development Plan which seeks to ensure a sustainable future and protect the special qualities of the Park.