The Local pLanning Authority considers that the proposal would compromise the aesthetic qualities of the remaining traditional windows and doors seen on the main farmhouse and undermine the integrity of this historic building and overall setting. Furthermore, insufficient justification has been provided to indicate that the alterations are necessary to achieve public benefit which would offset the harm caused. The proposal is therefore contrary to paragraphs 199 and 200 of the NPPF; and to the NYMNPA Local Plan 2022 Strategic Policy I which requires that alterations to listed buildings conserve the building and its setting in a manner appropriate to its significance.
The Local Planning Authority considers that the proposed replacement windows, being of standard double glazing units using float glass and applied glazing bars, fail to replicate the joinery details of the existing multi-paned single glazed windows and consequently would detract from the special architectural and historic character of the listed building contrary to Policy ENV11 of the NYMPA Local Plan 2022.
The Local Planning Authority considers that the proposed replacement door, being of a framed panel design with standard double glazing unit using float glass and applied glazing bars, fails to replicate the joinery details of the existing multi-paned single glazed doors and consequently would detract from the special architectural and historic character of the listed building contrary to Policy ENV11 of the NYMPA Local Plan 2022.